This week I watched Paul Fejos’ 1928 silent classic Lonesome, accompanied by the Alloy Orchestra. The film was made during a period of transition from silent cinema to talkies and is sometimes regarded to be the last great silent film. Actually, there are a few stretches of dialogue inserted at (inopportune) moments in the film primarily for commercial reasons and as an attempt to cater to a wider audience. These moments are forgettable at best and coupled with their ludicrous dialogues induce a sense of artificiality to an otherwise brilliant film.
The main characters, stereotypically named Mary and Jim, are working class people in New York city. The hustles and bustles of the city are captured in the film through frame overlays as we watch New York wake up to a chaotic frenzied morning. Jim and Mary are both alone and decide to attend a fair at Coney Island over a weekend, where they then meet each other. The narrative technique Fejos employs is pretty conventional as he tracks the lovers through a night of fanfare and merriment. There are a few scenes here that are hand-painted with color, but I found them to be quite disturbing.
To me, this film is not so much about loneliness as about the thrill and excitement of a new relationship. By setting the carnival as a backdrop, Fejos ensures a vivacity in the film that resonates with the palpable emotions of his lovers. Contrary to its title, this is more of a bubbling enthusiasm than a depressing foray into solitude. There’s humor injected in almost every sequence, from when Jim wakes up late in the morning to the time he listens to a recording of Irving Berlin’s “Always” in an attempt to drown his sorrows.
The end is especially spectacular, since having pushed itself to the limit near its climax (by seperating Mary and Jim), I thought it virtually impossible for the film to retreat without resorting to some cheap or mangled reasoning, but it managed to succintly avoid this in an extremely convincing and poetic finale that led to a long standing ovation from every one of us in the audience. Lonesome is easily a masterpiece of its time just waiting to be enjoyed and explored more fully.